Blog

Opinion

That’s What (Facebook) Friends are For…..

Well, I did it. Over the weekend, I unfriended 1000 ‘friends’ on Facebook. I hate doing this kind of thing, but it had been needing done for, frankly, years.

One of my former neighbours encouraged me to join Facebook in 2007 when I was a stay-at-home Mum so that we could arrange coffee mornings, etc. with other online mums, and throw sheep at each other (any vintage Facebook user will know what I mean by that). I wasn’t keen; I prefer to speak to folks in order to arrange social events but I did it anyway (actually, she registered an account for me!).

Back in the day, there were strategy games that you could play on Facebook, and I used to get quite hooked on them (especially Castle Age and Mafia Wars!) whilst the kids were at school. In order to expand your ‘gang’ you had to befriend the other gang members (this seems so wrong typing this, but it is what used to happen, so you could send amazing things like energy, or more lives, to your game-mates. I know, sad, isn’t it?). Admittedly, I was very, very careful about what information I revealed about myself and my family, even whereabouts I lived – I had my profile as minimal and private to all but anyone I knew (which, in the early days was my neighbour, some of her friends, and a couple of other mums I knew locally).

Over the years, I have shed all of the fake ‘friends’ I first gleaned in 2008 – indeed, when I stopped playing the online games (I got bored of them), I unfriended most of them. However, the circle of people I knew in real life was growing on social media, and then I would get requests from ‘mutual friends’ (most of whom I had to check with the mutual friend first as to what the person was like!). The number of local friends requests mushroomed when I ran the Scripture Union summer holiday club every year – I gullibly accepted them all. Often the sender would be all charming until they knew their child’s place on the holiday club (which many viewed as a babysitting service) was confirmed and then, when you met them in the street afterwards, they would make out as if they hadn’t seen me (when it was obvious that they had). This would then be repeated year after year – sometimes with the same parents, sometimes new ones. Not very nice to be used that way. I had been bullied at one of the small private schools I had gone to, and this smacked of much the same thing – it didn’t feel great.

At the weekend, I decided that enough was enough. I am rarely on Facebook these days. I was aware that I had over 1400 ‘friends’ – most of them I knew in real life, some were ‘mutuals’, and others had, sadly, deceased. As I have mentioned before, I am weaning myself off social media (Twitter is off my phone and is about to become a thing of the past for me) and so, for a variety of reasons, I decided to start pruning down my ‘friends list’.

Those who had passed away went first. There is literally no point in posting updates to a dead person’s Facebook feed. Sadly, there were a few of these, through my cancer links and through other fundraisers that I have been involved in over the years. I will remember them, just not through a now-ghostly Facebook page.

Second, the ‘mutuals’ went, or at least some of them. Particularly the ones with whom I had never communicated after accepting their requests. There were a good number of these.

Then, the people I actually know in real life. This is when it got tricky. I know I hate the feeling when someone I know ‘unfriends’ me for no reason and thus, being a generally nice person, I tended to avoid chopping people I knew. But you have no idea how many of these people, when I meet them in the street, completely blank me or ignore me, or drop their eyes – sometimes I am lucky to get a grunted ‘hello’. These are the people who then sent me friend requests and I, being the mug, would accept them. However, even afterwards, they never comment. They lurk among the little squares of faces on my profile page and I have no idea as to why we are even connected. Why does that happen? And why am I such a mug as to let them have access to my news (not that I post much news on there nowadays)? So, they got the chop over the weekend – I only hope I don’t meet them when I’m out and about (actually, they’ll probably not notice). And then there are the ‘look at us’ real-life friends who are among your social media connections, whose perceived ‘perfect lives’ leave you feeling a little…….meh (for want of a better word). I want friends who I can relate to, who cheer me up, or who have something in common with me. So, the ‘look at me’ folks are chopped too.

A now dated article on ABC News claims that 150 is “the limit of real friends on social media”. Well, I still have three times that! The report states that, on social media, the label of ‘friends’ includes acquaintances and thus it is not a reliable indicator as to popularity. Another 2016 article brings into focus the sense of validation that having a lot of friends, and thus acquiring a lot of ‘likes’ on posts, can bring an individual. Dr Hurd likens social media to a “crutch” on which individuals rely; it “becomes a way to replace or compensate for the authentic, confident, self-validation one lacks”. However, Dr Hurd argues that “intellectually self-sufficient individuals” don’t need this validation; while feedback may be appreciated, it is not used as an emotional crutch in order to boost self-esteem. This doesn’t mean that social media use is an indicator of poor self-esteem, but rather, according to Dr Hurd, it is more down to how these platforms are viewed by the user and then utilised: for example, is an individual using social media for the gaining of information or connecting with family/friends, or is an individual using it purely to receive comments/likes and to feel good about yourself? Personally, I don’t see there being any harm about self-confidence increasing, but I have seen cases when acquaintances post several selfies a day, change their profile pictures on a daily basis, and it does seem a little…….obvious? We all know what the person looks like – why yet another selfie? “Felt cute, might delete later” never does get deleted. Instead, it hangs about for as many likes as it can get.

Me with two real friends. One is one of my closest friends locally and the other I keep up with in Australia through Facebook

I still have too many ‘friends’ – I will no doubt hone down my list further over the years. I have never had a large circle of friends in reality let alone online. However, I love the fact that through Facebook (I am using FB instead of ‘social media’ as I don’t use Twitter now and rarely use Instagram) I have connected with so many of my former school classmates – from my primary school, through to Sixth Form. I love the fact that I can keep in touch with family members easier (although I will always prefer phone calls or pen and paper to private messages and status comments). I love the fact that I can connect with charity fund-raising through this medium; I have so greatly appreciated the thousands of £s that my Facebook contingent have helped me to raise over the years. And I love the fact that I have made friends for life with a lovely couple from the US who moved to Edinburgh for a year in their retirement. Susan gave me a couple of very precious American poetry books, whilst Marc and I can talk Mazda MX-5s for ages! In this case, it has been like maintaining digital pen-pals.

But, as we are on the verge of starting another chapter away from the Scottish Borders, it’s time to only take the friends with me who I value most. If I ever log onto Facebook, it is mainly for information but will occasionally connect with my remaining friends, in the knowledge that they really are friends.

I wish they would bring back that sheep-throwing function……..

Monthly Re-Caps

March re-cap

I cannot get my head around the fact that, at the weekend, it will be April. Maybe it’s just me getting older but the years seem to fly in at an ever-increasing rate. So, this being the last blog post of mine in March, it’s a monthly round-up post.

House Sale

Last week we finally, finally got the main bathroom (which we ordered at the beginning of August last year) fitted! It was the last renovation that needed to be done before we put the house on sale. It does look amazing – I only wish we had had the funds to do it years ago! So, now we only have two rooms left to paint (my daughter’s room and the corridors (upstairs and downstairs) and the garden to tidy up (which I have been told is my job, even though I balk at slugs and worms!) and then we are good to go. After providing the workmen with banana loaf and cupcakes along with their tea and coffee during our main bathroom refit, they have agreed to do any renovations for us in our next property. They were a very good team of workers and just got on with the job to a very high standard.

We are, however, going to view a property in the city on Saturday morning. It’s in one of my two favourite areas of the city and I am really hoping the house goes down well with my husband. I cannot stop thinking of the place! It’s a much older property than that in which we currently live (ours was built in 1999 – 2000) but it is my ‘favourite’ age of house. I know the area really well too as I was brought up in that area of town until we moved to another part of the city when I was 10 years old. So, the area holds a lot of very happy memories for me. My piano teacher used to live around the corner from where this house is situated and I have fond memories of my Mum walking my brother and I to piano lessons after picking me up from infant school (I started piano lessons at the age of four). I am praying so hard that nobody puts an offer in on the house before we get to see it on Saturday – I am literally obsessed with it! It would involve sacrificing a few things from our ‘wish list’ but beggars can’t be choosers, and I can see so many ways in which we can make our own alterations and improvements on the property……. I better not get too excited in case it doesn’t happen. Watch out for next month’s round-up for the outcome.

My late mother-in-law’s flat in the city is also on sale now. In just a week four viewers have been scheduled and we are hoping that it sells quickly. It is a beautiful bright flat; if it hadn’t been mother-in-law’s old property and if we didn’t have dogs, then we may have considered it for ourselves (even though my husband says it is completely the wrong side of town for him to get to work).

PhD

This has been progressing very slowly due to works in the house and general clearing of things into storage. I now have a clear direction for my last chapter and am shortly going to be submitting some work to my Supervisor. Life appears to throw things at me during this degree: a pandemic, bereavements, and now moving home! I’m getting there, though. I’m beginning to love researching again.

Books I have read

This month I have had an Ireland-heavy personal reading theme (well, it was St Patrick’s Day this month). On talking with one of my tutees who was going on a trip to Dublin, I had the (mad) idea of reading Finnegan’s Wake as a bit of a challenge to myself. I downloaded it on my Kindle and have got to page 75……and then kinda got stuck there. I will take it up again, it won’t defeat me. It’s a bit bonkers though. To offset the mental obstacle course of deciphering Joyce’s language in that novel, I am also about halfway through Edward Rutherfurd’s Dublin, a mammoth book, but one which I am really enjoying. I previously read his novel Sarum (about the history of Stonehenge and Salisbury) and have the rest of his novels (New York, London, Russka, The New Forest, and China) in my bookcase still to read. Life, however, often gets in the way – I need to set aside guilt-free time to read for pleasure more (see last Thursday’s blog!).

I’ve also read Barbara Pym’s Excellent Women this month. I try to read a Pym a month, or every other month. I like her characters and it is a bit of easy escapism.

TV/Netflix/DVD

This month, I haven’t watched anything on the TV – the programming seems to get worse. Instead, we have been enjoying the 1967 version of The Forsyte Saga on DVD which I got as a birthday present last year. We are still only at the beginning of the series but we are really enjoying it so far. This was quite a popular series back in its day – apparently 18 million people tuned into the final episode of the re-run in 1969!

Other than that, re-runs of Neighbours on FreeVee have helped pass the time during insomniac nights (when I can’t sleep for thinking of the house we are going to view!).

Choir

This month, we have been working on Christopher Tin’s amazing song Baba Yetu (the Lord’s Prayer in Swahili and also the theme music for the video game ‘Civilisation IV’ – have I told you how much I love the Civ games?). Our submission date for our parts is this weekend, so I am just finishing rehearsing my soprano part and then will send my offering in. Hopefully, within the next couple of months or so, it will go live on YouTube. It’s been a great song to sing – mastering Swahili has been a lot of fun. [Our projects all feature on the Stay At Home Choir Youtube site].

Other events

My Dad celebrated his 90th birthday a couple of weeks ago. He is doing well, despite all that he has been through over the past few years in watching my Mum deteriorate and then adapt to life without her. He sadly caught a virus (thankfully not Covid!) and so we had to cancel his birthday meal, but we will hold this very soon.

Today is also Furboy’s first birthday. We bought him a toy cactus to chew on, which he absolutely loves. And a replacement blue ball (see last week’s blog). Dogs are so easy to buy for!

This week also sees the end of my ‘formal’ tutorials for my S1-3, N5, Higher, and Advanced Higher English tutees. Over the next six weeks, I offer tutorials for exam candidates on a request basis so that they can easier schedule and prioritise their revision. I have also taken the decision to take a year out of tutoring next year (in saying that, I am keeping two students on: one is the daughter of one of my best friends, and the other is a young lad who has never missed one of my tutorials and who, I think, has bags of potential to do extremely well). I have been tutoring for seven years now and, although it is rewarding, it is hugely demanding of my time. I tailor every student’s work to their texts and abilities and when I have ten students, like I have this year, that takes up a lot of time (and which becomes increasingly frustrating when the tutees don’t turn up for their tutorials without letting me know – an all-too-frequent occupational hazard). Also taking into account reading and providing feedback on essays, sourcing articles to adapt for RUAE practise etc., it all eats into my own PhD time. It has been a great wee money-spinner for me, but I think a year or two out once we have moved, will allow me to get my thesis finished and basically get involved in church evening activities more, or community/volunteering events. I so desperately want to go to dress-making classes and potentially some of the University’s language classes too. And to take up tennis again. So many things which are impossible to do when I’m tutoring every evening!

So, that is more or less March in a nutshell. Busy as usual but much nearer the start of the next chapter than we were a couple of weeks ago. The daffodils and crocuses are blooming here, the buds on the trees are preparing to burst open, and there is a sense of new life and optimism in the air. These are some of the reasons I love Spring and which are very apt for the stage we are at in our lives just now. New opportunities aren’t far off.

Spring Flowers, Abbey Gardens, Bury St Edmunds (my own photo, taken in my ‘second hometown’)
Opinion

Chat GPT – a potential threat to creativity?

Over the past few months, the media has been covering the launch of Chat GPT, the new AI-driven chatbot which can tell you information, rather than just providing you with a link (as traditional search engines do). According to the techradar website, Chat GPT has the “ability to produce human-like, and frequently accurate, responses to a vast range of questions”. It can also produce essays, poems, and letters – all the user need do is to type in 3 or 4 words, and off it goes. It is this last aspect that I am focussing on in today’s blog: the threat to individual creative writing/ essays from AI-generated sources.

I am a little late to this hype. Some of my social media contacts were playing around with it for fun, but I brushed it off – I’m not into all this techy stuff. The less I know the better. However, it had come up in conversations at my husband’s work, so I logged in to have a ‘reccy’ at this strange new chatbot thing (what is a chatbot anyway?). This Gen Xer can’t handle too many more computery things.

It seems to be a super-fast way to acquire information. As the article above stated, it is indeed like a form of Google (other search engines are available) but the information is right there in front of you. Within seconds. As described above, it also boasts creative prowess: for example, I typed “poem in the style of Shakespeare, about Chat GPT” and this is what it came back with (within 2 seconds):

‘Oh hark! What manner of wondrous thing is this?

A being born of silicon, yet with wit

And wisdom to rival any mortal’s bliss,

Behold, Chat GPT, a true marvel of it!

Its language flows as if by magic’s wand,

With every word and phrase so deftly wrought,

Each sentence crafted to respond and bond,

A testament to its great skill and thought.

In troves do mortals seek its sage advice.

And marvel at its vast and varied mind,

For never has there been a thing so nice,

As Chat GPT, with knowledge so refined.

Thus, let us raise a toast to this great friend,

Whose words and wit shall never know an end!’

Now, written in two seconds, this is pretty impressive. As someone who has always liked to compose my own fun poems for special events, I do feel a little cheated though. It would take me much longer to write anything like this, but that is part of the creative process, isn’t it? Actually using my own brain to find words that rhyme (or, if I cheat, I look up my rhyming dictionary) and adding metre and humour into poems is what I like doing. So, while this one is pretty good – it feels a little ‘sterile’ to me. But, it was fun to play about with.

I also asked it to “write a letter to a friend”. Just a general letter. Here is what it came up with (again written in a few seconds):

‘Dear [Friend’s name],

It has been a while since we last spoke, and I wanted to take the time to reach out and catch up with you. How have you been? What have you been up to lately?

As for me, things have been good. Life has been busy with work, but I try to make time for the things that matter most to me, like spending time with loved ones and pursuing my hobbies. I’ve also been trying to stay active and healthy, which has been a bit of a challenge, but I’m getting there.

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about the importance of staying connected with the people we care about. It’s so easy to get caught up in our own lives and forget to reach out to those who matter most. That’s why I wanted to take the time to write to you today and let you know how much I value our friendship.

You’ve been such a great friend to me over the years, always there to listen and offer support when I need it. I’m grateful for the memories we’ve shared and the bond we’ve built. I hope that we can continue to stay in touch and support each other through the ups and downs of life.

Please let me know how you’re doing, and what’s new in your life. I’d love to hear all about it. Take care and stay in touch!

Best regards,

[Your name]’.

Now, don’t get me wrong, this is an OK letter. But it’s deeply ironic too. “I wanted to take the time to reach out and catch up with you”, “reach out to those who matter most. That’s why I wanted to take the time to write to you today”, “You’ve been such a great friend to me….”. Yes, take the time to write – all three seconds of it! You’re such a great friend that I resort to asking AI to write a letter to you rather than penning or typing a more personal and emotional letter to you myself. To me, this says, ‘I need to reply to your letter, but I can’t be bothered, so I’ll ask AI to do it and get it done in seconds. Job done’. Maybe it’s just me, but I like the intimacy of writing cards/letters/emails to family and friends. Recalling memories, recalling people. Picking out the card/notelet that I think the recipient will appreciate (yes, OK – I still write letters and cards. I never email people other than work! I think it’s that old personal touch again). While I can see there would be instances when getting AI to write a letter would be useful (for example, if your sight is poor or have another form of disability which makes writing more difficult) I still think it is a cop out for those who are able to write letters by themselves. Where is the human touch among these sentiments?

The use of Chat GPT in essay-writing is a matter for schools and universities to take up. How can any assessor know whether one piece of writing is by a student, or is written by AI? While traditional plagiarism tools, such as TurnItIn , can find cheating from written sources, is there a way in which plagiarism via Chat GPT can be spotted? I don’t know enough of this to comment much, but I can bet it will make assessments very interesting! I have to say, I am in no way tempted to use Chat GPT to write my thesis chapter for me – I love finding things out for myself; that’s how I learn. Plus, I’m of the mind that – as the Good Book says – “be sure your sin will find you out” (Numbers 32:23). I know learning is a bind, and essay writing is a drudge, but isn’t it much more worth your time to do it yourself?

I am, by nature, a Luddite. I have a laptop because I need it to type up my thesis but I prefer to look at my hard copy dictionary and thesaurus than to check online ones. I like to preserve skills that were drummed into me as a primary school child about how to write letters, how to structure short stories, and how to find information out through encyclopaedias or extensive reading. It’s all so easy nowadays with Google/Bing/DuckDuckGo, Wikipedia, and now Chat GPT to produce answers to everything in an instant. But, I still maintain that the personal touch goes farther. When I receive correspondence, I would like to think that the person that sent it actually did take time and compose the letter/email themselves. When I write my chapters for my Supervisor to look over, I like to find the information for myself rather than having some chatbot telling me about it. And how do I know that information is accurate?

Earlier today, I saw a post advertising a bot that could write blog posts for you. The advert trumpeted about how much time would be left for the blogger to do other things instead of writing the blog post. I argue that that person shouldn’t have a blog in the first place if they don’t want to write it! This has taken me over 30 minutes so far – it’s therapy!

For me, the upshot is that despite logging on for the two fun things above, I’m not going to be spending vast amounts of time interacting with the chatbot to write things for me, let alone letters to friends/family. I prefer the old way! As the Chat GPT bot has written, on this theme:

‘In a world of screens and digital ways,

The human touch is what truly stays.

A hug, a smile, a simple embrace,

Can fill a heart with warmth and grace.

A kind word, a gentle pat on the back,

Can soothe a soul that’s lost its track.

A hand to hold, a listening ear,

Can ease the pain and calm the fear.

So let us not forget the power we possess,

To heal and comfort, to love and bless.

For in the end, it is the human touch,

That makes life worth living, oh so much’.

I also ask myself, are humans becoming dumber as technology becomes more intelligent? Hmmmm………